Kind words...

Katie, First-time homebuyer, Fitchburg, WI
My fiancé and I worked with Kayleigh last year to buy our first home and it was such a smooth and fun experience! We had no idea what we were doing and she talked us through everything, worked with our annoying schedules, and helped us to buy our dream home. She did such an amazing job explaining  everything in terms we could understand and guiding us through every decision making process we had. I can’t imagine working with anyone else, if you’re looking for an amazing realtor, Kayleigh’s your girl!
Rose, Seller/buyer, Oregon, WI
Kayleigh has been my realtor twice - when I was a buyer, and most recently a seller. She is extremely knowledgeable, professional, thorough, always keeps you up to date, and treats her clients like family. More importantly, Kayleigh is trustworthy. Kayleigh understood my extremely particular needs  and wants in a house as a buyer and also catered to my needs and negotiated on my behalf as a seller. When the process got stressful, Kayleigh took the time to explain the realities of certain situations with pure honesty and went above and beyond my expectations to ensure that I was satisfied as a client. I couldnt imagine going through the buying or selling process with anyone else, and would hands down choose Kayleigh again if I went through another buying or selling process.
Alyssa, First-time homebuyer, Madison, WI
Kayleigh was always friendly, available, and approachable. My husband and I were way over our heads as first-time home buyers and she always framed things ways we could understand. She was flexible with scheduling viewings and coordinated excellently with all sellers so we didn't have to sweat any  of the details. She also made perfect recommendations for a mortgage lender and home inspector. She really knew what we were looking for in a home but also knew everything about the business and was an invaluable part of our home buying process. We could not recommend her more!
Andrea, Seller/buyer, Middleton, WI
Excellent knowledge of the area we moved into and was available at all times of the day to help with questions! Went above and beyond to make the whole buying process seamless. Would recommend over and over again to family and friends needing a realtor in the area!
Kyle, First-time homebuyer, Madison, WI
"Kayleigh and Nick are a class act. Kayleigh met with me and was supportive from the beginning. She worked hard to help me understand what I wanted and helped me put it into words so that she could look for properties that matched my criteria. She was patient and understanding and let me make my own decisions on my own timeline. Kayleigh and Nick even take the time out of their day to notice my social media comments about first time homeowner challenges and send me supportive messages or links to resources to help me out.  You don't hear about that kind of legitimate follow through these days."
Sara, First-time homebuyer, Fitchburg, WI
"Kayleigh helped me find my dream home! She asked me questions to help narrow down the search and worked within my budget to find the perfect place. She was very knowledgeable, took the time to answer all of my questions and made me feel valued during the whole process. I would definitely recommend her! "
Ryan, Lender
"Kayleigh is a great Realtor, flat out.  Her attention to detail and care for her clients is amazing.  I am a mortgage lender and have been in business for 16 years and I think she is one of the best.  Helping clients work through any issue that comes their way, communicating at a high level and doing it all with a smile!  You should feel very confident trusting Kayleigh with your buying or selling needs."
Brent, Lender
“Kayleigh is honest and a hard-worker.  When I’m working with Kayleigh, I trust that she will do the right thing for her clients best interests.” 
Home isn't just a place, it's a feeling.


  • Instagram - White Circle
  • w-facebook

© 2023 by Kayleigh Cleary-Stark Company Realtors.  

Proudly created with